Whether it’s a panini, a hoagie, a po’ boy, or a fried chicken sando – everyone has a favorite, go-to sandwich. Here’s the Portland Old Port guide to a few of Portland, Maine’s best sandwiches to help you get (b)ready to celebrate National Sandwich Day. See what we did there?
1124 Forest Avenue, Portland, ME, USA Po’ Boys and Pickle…
Po’ Boys and Pickles
If a heartier sandwich is more your thing, you’ll want to check out Po’ Boys and Pickles.
The original “poor boy” sandwich came from down south in New Orleans during the Great Depression era, made up of fried potatoes, gravy, and bits of roast beef on French bread. The aim was a hearty, stick to your bones meal of a sandwich, not unlike the hearty, oversized sandwiches Po’ Boys and Pickles is serving up today. Let us suggest the Cheeseburger Po’Boy with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, ketchup, mustard, mayo and onions. Yum!
Duckfat was born out of the desire to bring hand cut Belgian frites to Portland. It only then seemed natural to pair their frites with hot, delicious pressed sandwiches. A person favorite is their Broccolini Panini (debuted this spring) with raclette, Fern Hill Farm goat cheese, and romesco.
Duckfat’s owners Rob Evans and Nancy Pugh believe you should know where your food comes from and work daily to source their ingredients from New England. Here in Portland, we love to see local supporting local.
18 Monument Sq, Portland, ME 04101, USA Shays Grill Pub
Shays Grill Pub is the spot where your sandwich dreams come true, especially those craving fried chicken goodness! Their menu is a masterpiece of flavor, with stars like the Coop’s Hot Chicken, boasting buttermilk-fried chicken, Nashville spice, and chili oil. Don’t miss the Sweet & Spicy Chicken Sandwich, featuring deep-fried sweet and spicy chicken breast, bacon, cheddar, and a side of ranch. But the real magic is in their ever-changing specials, guaranteeing a thrilling sandwich adventure every visit.
If a classic Philly-style hoagie does it for you, Ramona’s, where Philly native Josh Sobel is owner and chef, then this is the place for you. You can trust us when we say Philadelphians know a thing or two about hoagies.
The Turkey Caesar Hoagie is a play on a Chicken Caesar, with a heaping portion of roasted turkey topped with pickled red onions, lettuce, parmesan, and Caesar mayo, slapped onto a fresh roll. Just don’t call it a sub, it’s a hoagie.
7 Union St, Portland, ME 04101 Butcher Burger
Butcher Burger
The Chicken and Waffle sandwich from Butcher Burger- not quite breakfast and not quite lunch. This sando is a rule breaker and that’s just what we are looking for. What’s not to love about crispy fried chicken and a fried egg squished between two Belgian waggles, covered in real Maine maple syrup? Indulge yourself.
The Jabberwocky, an utter nonsensical beast of a sandwich, is for the meat lovers. House roast beef, house pastrami, North Country uncured bacon, local swiss cheese, BBQ sauce, red onion, tomato on sourdough or multi-grain.
Owner of Cera, Steven Lacount, has had a lifelong obsession with sandwiches and a lifetime frustration trying to find unique sandwiches with high quality ingredients. So, he set out to create Cera, which serves high quality food that is “good for you, good for the planet”. Cera also offers a full range of vegetarian and vegan options in salads, sandwiches, wraps and paninis.
Sissle & Daughters Cheesemongers and Grocers
107 Washington Avenue, Portland, ME, USA
At The Cheese Shop they say, “great food is as profound as it is simple”, and their sandwiches are just that – profoundly delicious, yet simple. Take, for instance, The Parisian: Jambon de Paris, Comte, local greens, and housemade dijonnaise on a Standard Baking Co. Baguette. The simplicity of their creations help your taste buds focus on and appreciate each carefully selected sandwich component. Bon appétit!
Salvatore’s Hoagie shop is a Philadelphia inspired hoagie shop, featuring cheesesteaks, Italian roast porks, hoagies, and more. Everything is made from scratch in their kitchen, including the bread which is baked in house. Both pickup and delivery ordering are available.
Nestled in Portland’s Woodford neighborhood, The Local Press is a true sandwich haven that promises a delicious adventure. The Local Press usually has a delightful surprise or two up their sleeve – frequent specials! One fan-favorite you simply can’t miss is “The Shepherd’s Pie-nini,” a tantalizing twist that combines the comfort of shepherd’s pie with the handheld convenience of a panini. Alongside these specials, they craft divine sandwiches using Boar’s Head meats and cheeses, alongside a rotating selection of local delicacies and fresh produce. Their daily-baked bread from Bottos Bakery provides the perfect canvas for these culinary masterpieces.
Noble Pizzeria and Barbecue is sure to do more than just “meat” your expectations! Recently moved to their new location on Stevens Ave, they bring wood fired pizza and BBQ to the neighborhood- Focusing on thin crust crispy pizza, and smoked meat Sandwiches. Pictured here is their Pastrami Reuben. Other fan favorites include their smoked turkey sandwich, and their smoked prime brisket.
For more sandwich spots, check out The Muthah Truckah, Leavitt and Sons, and Bahn Appetit!
